理论探讨

基于数据变权预防指标人为操控期刊评价研究——以管理学期刊为例

  • 俞立平 ,
  • 夏芳
展开
  • 常州大学商学院 江苏 213159 浙江农林大学经济管理学院 杭州 311300  
俞立平,男,1967 年生,常州大学商学院教授,博士生导师。 夏 芳,女,1975 年生,浙江农林大学经济管理学院讲师(通讯作者)。

网络出版日期: 2022-07-12

基金资助

本文系国家社会科学基金项目“学术期刊评价——指标创新与方法研究”(项目编号:21FTQB016)、浙江省自然科学基金重点项目“制造业从
数量型创新向质量型创新转型机制研究”(项目编号:Z 21G 030004)和浙江省重点建设高校优势特色学科(浙江工商大学统计学)的研究成果。

Research on the Evaluation of Journals Based on Artificial Manipulation of  DataVariable Weight Prevention Indicators

  • Yu Liping ,
  • Xia Fang
Expand
  • School of Business,Changzhou University, Jiangsu,213159 College of Economics and Management, Zhejiang A&F University,Hangzhou ,311300

Online published: 2022-07-12

摘要

[ 目的/意义] 在学术期刊评价中,过度自引和人为操纵载文量是两个比较重要的问题,必须设法加以纠
正。[方法/过程]文章提出采用关键指标数据变权来防止文献计量指标的人为操纵问题,其基本原理是通过变权
函数对评价指标原始数据进行惩罚或激励,并将自引和载文量纳入评价体系,然后再进行评价。[结果/结论]本文
基于中国知网管理学期刊数据进行了实证,研究发现:必须重视学术期刊载文量与自引的人为操控问题;采用关
键指标数据变权可以有效地解决指标人为操纵问题;评价体系应注意评价目标与防止人为操纵的平衡;建议优秀
期刊适当扩大载文量。

本文引用格式

俞立平 , 夏芳 . 基于数据变权预防指标人为操控期刊评价研究——以管理学期刊为例[J]. 情报资料工作, 2022 , 43(4) : 36 -43 . DOI: 10.12154/j.qbzlgz.2022.04.004

Abstract

[Purpose/significance] In the evaluation of academic journals, excessive self-citation and artificial manipu ?
lation of article quantity are two important problems, and it is necessary to amend it. [Method/process] The paper pro?
poses to use the variable weight of key index data to prevent the artificial manipulation of the biblimetric indicators.
The basic principle is to punish or motivate the original data of the evaluation index through the variable weight func?
tion, and to include the self-citation and article quantity into the evaluation system to evaluate. [Result/conclusion]
The paper makes an empirical study based on the data of CNKI management journals, the research shows that we must
attach importance to the artificial manipulation of the article quantity and self-citation in academic journals. It can ef?
fectively solve the artificial manipulation of index problem by using variable weight of key index data. The evaluation
system should pay attention to the balance between the evaluation goal and the prevention of artificial manipulation. It
is suggested that excellent journals should expand the article quantity.
文章导航

/